Wednesday, June 3, 2009

Ad-Deen Approach of the Quran. – Part Two

Secondly, I do not find that the Quran ever taught blind faith. Somehow, this “faith” element” seemed to have been given a twist and “hype” it does not deserve in the objective search for knowledge and Truth by the religious folks. “Faith” has also been equated with blind belief, it seems. I must clarify that I am not suggesting that “faith” and “belief” do not have any role. It is the blind “faith” and “blind belief” that I am unable to accept. Contrary to what some religious folks say, I find that the Quran emphatically require the seeker to evaluate and query even that belief which is held by our parents and forefathers.

“When it is said to them: "Follow what God has revealed:" They say: "No! we shall follow the ways of our fathers." What! even though their fathers were void of wisdom and guidance? (Quran: 2.170) [see also verses: 5:104, 7:70, 11:87, 12:40, 21:53 and many more with the same message]

Obviously parents deserve respect and love for they are good people. However, let us not confuse “good people” with people with wisdom and knowledge. They, too, like most us, may be blind followers. For example, we do not follow the ways of our fathers by posting letters all the time, do we? We now use emails frequently. Religious approach makes us illogical. Deen approach allows us to use common sense and thinking. Another series of verses from the Quran that is relevant and interesting to consider are the following:

“No! they say: "We found our fathers following a certain path, and we do guide ourselves by their footsteps." (Quran: 43:022)

“Just in the same way, whenever We sent a warner/giver of notice before you to any people, the wealthy and arrogant ones among them said: "We found our fathers following a certain path, and we will certainly follow in their footsteps." (Quran 43:23)

“He (the giver of notice) said: "What! Even if I brought you better guidance than that which you found your fathers following?" They said: "For us, we deny that you are sent (on a mission at all)." (Quran 43:24)

It should now be obvious that sincere and intelligent inquiry is encouraged by the Quran strongly. In fact, the Quran goes on to say that on Judgment Day, we cannot blame our parents for our refusal to evaluate and think.

“In the event you should say: "Our fathers before us may have taken false gods, but we are merely (their) descendants after them: will you then destroy us because of the deeds of men who were futile?" (Quran 7:173)

The religious approach on the other hand requires a total, unquestioning acceptance coupled with the dubious notion of “fear of being sinful if questions are asked”. The religious approach negates the fact that one may already be misled by never understanding what one believes in.

On the contrary, I find the Quran explicit on the requirement of thinking, verification and evaluation of whatever you experience or hear in life. You are not expected to believe or accept anything without rational basis and or that which cannot be made sense of by using any or all the five senses plus the cognitive process. For instance, it is by using some of the five senses plus the cognitive process that I come to believe that “wind” exists even though I am unable to see it with my eyes. If you believe something without thinking or verification, you are likely to be fooled. This is Reality.

“And follow/accept not that of which you have no knowledge; for every act of hearing, or of seeing or of (feeling in) the heart will be enquired into (on the Day of Reckoning). (Quran: 17:36)

Even though I was “born into a Muslim family”, I like to think that it was the above verse (17:36) that actually sparked my journey to delve into the Quran seriously and eventually led me to accept the Quran as a practical guidance from the Creator.

Anyway, back to our discussion, for example, it does not matter if you blindly believe that a knife will not penetrate your body. It will if it is sharp enough. Once you know the characteristics of the knife and the human body, you will understand the physics of why the knife will penetrate your body. You may then believe it when someone else tells you to be careful with a knife. This “belief” is grounded on facts. The Ad-deen approach of the Quran is precisely that – get your facts right in life.

In the case of the person who deeply believe that knife will not penetrate normal skin, he will certainly think that he is right. We tend to get carried away with “religious fervor” due to the religious mentality. I have often seen people who have abdicated the thinking process being called “very religious”. Some of them are admired and that baffles me. Believing that you are right does not and will not make you right. The only way you can be right is if your belief is consonant or consistent with the facts.

I admit there are certain matters that require belief that may not be contemporarily comprehensible yet. For example, the belief that it is possible for someone in Malaysia to talk with and see another person in America. It is possible today with internet. However, this idea may be unimaginable just 30 years ago. My point is that the religious approach emphasizes on blind faith in substantial and fundamental matters of practical life. The Adeen approach on the other hand emphasizes substantially on reasoning, common sense, knowledge and REALITY. Less hype and more facts.


NEXT: Ad-Deen Approach of the Quran. – Part Three


jon pour do care said...

Salam Bro. Jay,

Well said ! Just can't wait for part 3 !

P.S. Eh ! Semua berapa part uh ?

helmi said...

All people were born as muslims until faith (believing in one Creator)enters thair heart and became a mukmin.

Dr said...

Science is the antidote to blind faith. For example, the world is no longer flat, there really is no Moon God because Neil Armstrong didn't meet him, earthquakes are caused by tectonic shifts and the sin city that is New York will never be hit by an earthquake as it is not on a fault line, there is nobody on Mt Kinabalu, the heart is just a muscular pump not the centre of one's faith etc etc. Allahu a'lam.

Jahamy said...


well said.


Silly Korn said...


Agreed with what Dr said. Science is the pure antidote. I've once heard during Friday prayer khutbah, one khatib said that he condemned the Earth Hour day because he feels that the global warming problem is "balasan tuhan krana kita slalu mlupakanNya & kita harus redha menerima". What a low. I wonder whether he went to see the doctor if he's sick. Or he just chant to God to heal him n doing nothing.


Jahamy said...

silly korn

well said! That's the difference between "ad-deen" and religious approach. One is proactive, the other is purely ritualistic!

jon pour do care said...

Salam Bro. Jay,

The 'honda, honda, honda chant' in your previous article reminds me of this article from

Dear friends,
There is supposed to be no clergy in Islam. Yet, it is not only thriving but getting inherited!
‘Hadhrat Shaikh Mufti-e-Azam Maulana’ Muhammad Shafi Uthmani Saheb (1897-1976) was the Mufti Azam (Chief Edict Dispenser) of Pakistan. These days his son ‘Hadhrat Shaikh Mufti-e-Azam Maulana’ Muhammad Rafi Uthmani Saheb holds the deplorable ‘prestigious’ office. Shafi’s other son is also a well-known Mufti. ‘Hadhrat Shaikh Mufti Maulana’ Muhammad Taqi Uthmani Saheb has issued an official edict: “Prophet Muhammad (S) has visited an elderly Sheikh and informed him that Pakistan is under the wrath of Allah these days. The exalted prophet told him that the entire nation, every individual, must recite “Ayah Kareemah” 70,000 times each and the oncoming doom will be averted.”
When such are the priests, God save the congregation - or will He?
Reciting the partial Ayah 100,000 times is a common group chore among N2I women whenever they wish to ward off some calamity.
The term “Ayah Kareemah” is applied to a part of verse 21:87 - “LA ILAHA ILLA ANTA SUBHANAKA INNI KUNTU MIN AZ-ZAALIMEEN”. [O God! You are Glorious. It was me who was of the wrongdoers.]
An interesting anecdote goes here. Prophet Yunus (Jonah) was swallowed by a whale (this never happened) and lived in her belly for 40 days. Finally, he recited this partial reciting 100,000 times and the whale vomited him out on the shore, wow! See QXP 21:87.
Is not every verse of the Qur’an ‘Kareem’ (Honorable)? Allah did not name 21:87 as “Ayah Kareemah”.
Is it difficult to understand that repeating any verse over and over will only waste our time and energy? Did Allah command us to do that? Is the Qur’an a Book of guidance or mantras?
2:231 … Do not make Allah’s verses a laughing stock …
Followers of N2I (The Number Two Islam) may continue doing what they will.
Dr. Shabbir